Superfund Evasion?

In the 1996 Waste Management Annual Report the provision of funds for Superfund costs was reduced by about 90% from previous years. With a Republican Congress, shareholder demand for higher profits and a new management, the StopWMX Campaign wonders if there is a campaign by Waste Management to subvert Superfund cleanups. They have at least 114 sites they are responsible for. This Powell Road Landfill in Dayton shows a tactic WMI has used to attempt to reject the EPA order to clean up the site. The cost estimate is over $20 million of which WMI would take a big share. We ask you to send us information by EMAIL of what information you have on WMI and Superfund sites.


Waste Management Inc. (WMI) gained ownership of the Powell Road Landfill (PRL) in 1984 when it bought SCA Chemical Services of Ohio, Inc. Powell landfill was placed on the Superfund National Priorities List that same year! In 1985 PRL was closed. In 1985 the site report was completed by Roy T. Weston, Inc. (a firm which in 1990 settled a fraud suit by EPA for doctoring the technical data and distorting information. Weston paid $750,000). Despite the 1993 decision to clean up this site, WMI has stalled all these years and now plans to not clean up the site.

"Powell Road Landfill site occupies about 7 acres along Powell Road, near Dayton, Ohio, in northern Montgomery County. The Great Miami River flows along the southern boundary of the site. ... Municipal, commercial, industrial and residential properties are scattered within a one-mile radius of the site.

"The site is located in a former sand and gravel pit and has been elevated approximately 40 feet above the surrounding terrain. Surface water runoff drains south toward the nearby Miami river. The proximity of the river to the site provides a pathway for its potential contamination. The soil which underlies the site is very permeable, providing easy passage for contaminants to travel downward from the site into the aquifer present beneath the site. Public water supply well fields that tap into the aquifer are located south and east of the site." EPA Fact Sheet - PRL Site, February 1988)

In February 1992 the Remedial Investigation Feasibility Study (conducted by SCA (WMI)!), found volatile liquids and gases including 21 VOCs (volatile organic chemicals) including 2-Butanone, acetone, 4-methyl 2-pentanone, zylences, and toluene. The report recommended a number of cleanup remedial actions.

"Powell Road Landfill is a public health hazard because of possible past exposures and the potential for human exposure to site-related chemicals. There are chemicals present in groundwater that are considered to be carcinogens, while other chemicals may adversely affect the liver and kidneys. ... PRL poses a public health hazard because of the potential for exposure to VOCs in drinking water supplies." PUBLIC HEALTH ASSESSMENT, Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, April 22., 1993.

On September 30, 1993 the Ohio EPA determined a remedial action estimated to cost $20.51 million, "The selected remedial action includes the following components: institutional controls; improved landfill cap with liner; excavation of contaminated soils; consolidation of excavated soils under landfill cap; ground water monitoring; flood protection; storm water controls; active landfill gas collection with flare; leachate extraction; on-site leachate treatment; extraction of ground water from the shallow aquifer adjacent to the landfill; on-site ground water treatment; and discharge of treated ground water and leachate to the river." (Letter from Dir of OEPA to Regional Administrator US EPA, September 30, 1993)

Since then, WMI has done more testing and claims that the dangers of the landfill no longer exist. They are recommending that there be no major cleanup. The "official" Miami Valley Landfill Coalition, Citizens for Responsible Cleanup of the PRL, protest vigorously that the tests were not made to the bottom of the landfill where the dangerous liquid and volatile chemicals lie. MVLC may be contacted at 212 Center College St., Yellow Springs, OH 45387-1527 (937-767-2854). Letters are encouraged to be sent to EPA Region V, 77 West Jackson Blvd, Chicago, IL 60604-3590.

Return to the STOP WMX Home Page
Return to Fact Page


Make a Public Comment or send us some e-mail